What Happens at the End of Baby Daddy

The "mystery" surrounding Historia's pregnancy is not adventitious. It'south entirely deliberate equally the final reveal of the begetter's identity is virtually probable going to be related to an important plot point and the upcoming Ch. 138 is the perfect opportunity for that as Ch. 137 ended with Eren'due south supposed defeat. Almost current theories explore the idea of Eren re-activating the Rumbling by touching Historia's newly-born baby as it will probably inherit the Fauna Titan, because that Zeke died without being eaten. If this turns out to exist right so Isayama definitely had no other pick but to conceal the details of Historia's pregnancy from a narrative standpoint, because if the readers had known that Eren was the father from the beginning and then they could also have hands guessed that Eren might use the baby as some sort of backup plan.

Manifestly, in that location'southward several issues with the suggestion that Eren is the infant daddy and this postal service aims to disprove them.

"The timeline doesn't add up."

As it can be seen in panels B and C, Historia lied to the Survey Corps about the date of conception, giving them a later ane, which is why no one expected her to become into labor mid-Rumbling. At present that she has started giving birth before, the strongest statement against Eren being the male parent has been debunked every bit he was nevertheless on Paradis ten months ago, meaning that Historia and him could've easily done the deed merely before his difference for Marley.

"Information technology was confirmed repeatedly that the farmer is the father."

Of form, that'southward certainly however a possibility Only at that place'southward a few inconsistencies/facts that don't brand sense nigh information technology.

Firstly, it would be a weak plot line as not just is the farmer completely irrelevant to the manga only it would mean that Historia found herself exactly in the state of affairs Eren wanted to avoid (breeding kids for the sake of a political ulterior motive).

While the Paradis officials discuss the pregnancy, we see Historia chatting with the farmer (panel D) and a hooded figure observing them. The spectator is undoubtedly Eren as he was the only SC fellow member shown to be visiting Historia. The fashion in which panels D, E and F are staged pretty much implies as to what is occuring.

1. Historia approaches the farmer: console E infers that Historia was the one to initiate this chat, perhaps either to ask him to be the father of her child OR to plead him to pretend to be the father of the child (because if rumour had spread nigh Eren being her baby daddy and so all Hell would take broken loose on the island).

2. The farmer looks nervous: both aforementioned tasks are quite the big deal; however, his reaction is rather weak and then I'thousand more inclined to believe that she offered him the less challenging 1 (to be a fake father).

3. Historia is visibly upset past something: could be due to having to get pregnant out of necessity OR could be due to being disturbed on a deeper level every bit she would be subjecting her baby to a similar fate as her one (growing upwards on a farm, not knowing their existent male parent as the chances of Eren dying are pretty high).

4. Eren watches from afar: why in the world would Eren have to be there if he'southward not personally involved? It could be contended that his reason for being in that location is that the baby is his secret strategy if his main one fails. But he could also be there to make sure everything goes smoothly since if the farmer refuses to human activity as a male parent for the public then Eren and Historia would accept to make him quiet (remove his memories, etc.).

"Eren would never let the babe inherit the Beast Titan every bit it goes against his morals."

To brainstorm with, Eren could've found a way to destroy the titan source matter and permanently complimentary all Eldians from being Subjects of Ymir for all we know. In such a scenario, information technology's not far-fetched to assume that he would see this as a temporary inconvenience that can eventually be fixed.

What is more, I'd similar to remind everyone that Eren often goes against the things he preaches and here are two notable examples:

This is the man, who proceeded with his Marley infiltration plan even though he was fully aware that Sasha would dice (panel Yard) in the rescue mission (he was shown envisaging it afterward kissing Historia's hand). Eren doesn't want to risk the wellbeing of his friends BUT he will practice it if it gets in the way of his goal (he might brand exceptions for Mikasa and Armin, though).

MOREOVER, Eren firmly believes that "in that location is zip farther removed from freedom than ignorance" and nonetheless, he proposes to Historia the alternative of erasing her memories (panel H), which literally contradicts his values. This verifies that Eren is a bit of a hypocrite when information technology comes to achieving his dream.

So to answer the major question: the likelihood of Eren using the baby is not slim at all!

"Eren doesn't have a potent enough bond with Historia." / "Eren doesn't dearest Historia romantically."

Shipping aside, Eren and Historia relate to each other more than they do to anyone else. Their connection is and then great that the scene of Eren freeing Ymir (an essential moment of the manga) mirrors the scene of Historia freeing Eren every bit this astonishing mail past u/avocadobeach shows us: Paths and Cavern Scene Parallels. This is vital as Eren is purely driven by his want for freedom. Freeing Ymir is the embodiment of his struggle and the inspiration behind it was Historia.

Here's an actress post on Tumblr (Eren's Choice: Mikasa and Historia, Betwixt Selflessness and Cocky) that brings to the fore a very intriguing point: Mikasa (trust in his friends) and Historia (trust in himself) represent the toughest decision Eren has to make in his life and while he initially leans towards the first, he ultimately chooses the 2nd choice.

Now that we've established that Historia has impacted Eren tremendously, let me add a further particular. In that location's an axiomatic parallel to Odin and his wife, Frigg – Odin is on an ceaseless quest for knowledge (like Eren) and Frigg is associated with foresight and wisdom (like Historia, who is always there to provide Eren with access to knowledge – for instance, even when he was doubting his existence also equally his father's deeds, Historia was there to "enlighten" him).

Historia (both intentionally and unintentionally) aids Eren in his journey to freedom so information technology's reasonable to presume that she appeals to his basic nature, which is something not many other characters practice.

And finally, Eren's special attitude towards Historia is emphasized in the way he speaks near her. While his friends are, generally, grouped (Armin/Mikasa or Armin/Mikasa/Jean/Connie/Sasha), Historia is e'er mentioned seperately and individually. On pinnacle of that, he stubbornly refuses to sacrifice her no matter what. As I explained earlier, Eren accepted that he had to sacrifice Sasha only is "non prepared" to exercise the same with Historia. He kept his oral fissure close for 4 years as to not endanger her. That could only be because: A) he does love her in his own way (fifty-fifty if it's not passionate romantic love as nosotros've had no indication of that so far, he associates her with being his driving force), or B) he intensely sympathizes with her equally they take similar experiences and sees himself in her to an extent. Either way, it's not unimaginable that he would want to take a child with her.

LMK what y'all recollect!

brownthentlen.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/titanfolk/comments/li19po/all_the_proof_you_need_that_eren_is_the_father_of/